One of Prime Video’s most heavily criticized films, Culpa Mia (My Fault), has made a surprising comeback on the platform’s global chart following the release of its equally panned sequel, Culpa Tuya (Your Fault). Despite holding a 0% score on Rotten Tomatoes, the Spanish-language romantic drama is once again in the streamer’s top three worldwide, proving that negative reviews aren’t always enough to keep audiences away.

From Wattpad Novel to Viral Film Franchise

Released in 2023, Culpa Mia was adapted from Mercedes Ron’s Wattpad novel, which already had a massive online following before Amazon Prime Video picked it up for a film adaptation. The story centers on Noah, a young woman who finds herself drawn romantically to her stepbrother after her mother remarries.

The sequel, Culpa Tuya, released in December 2024, continues this controversial saga, with a third installment still to come. While critics dismiss the films as paper-thin in plot and heavy in clichés, fans of the original Wattpad novels continue to support the adaptation, driving massive streaming numbers.

Critical Reception: 0% Rotten Tomatoes Score

Both Culpa Mia and Culpa Tuya have been universally panned by critics. Out of the 13 reviews between the two films, only one offered anything resembling a positive note. The criticisms point to:

• Wooden acting
• Overuse of clichés
• Weak storyline stretched into sequels

For critics, the franchise is a textbook example of a viral online phenomenon that simply doesn’t translate well to the big screen.

Audience Reception: A Complete Contrast

Despite the critical backlash, audiences tell a different story. On Rotten Tomatoes, the audience score sits at a strong 86%, suggesting fans are more than satisfied. Most viewers tuning in are familiar with Mercedes Ron’s books, meaning they know exactly what to expect from the movies.

The films may not win over critics, but they deliver precisely what fans of the franchise want: a faithful adaptation of the Wattpad romance they fell in love with.

Why Culpa Mia Works for Fans, But Not for Critics

The disconnect between critics and audiences comes down to expectations.

• For critics: originality, depth, and strong performances are essential—and Culpa Mia offers none of these.
• For fans: loyalty to the source material and indulgence in a guilty-pleasure romance is more than enough.

Prime Video seems to have recognized the power of this formula, pushing ahead with the full trilogy despite the overwhelming negative press.

Prime Video’s Viral Gamble

With Culpa Tuya now streaming and a third installment on the way, Amazon has doubled down on the idea that audience demand outweighs critical reception. Much like Netflix’s success with Wattpad-inspired dramas, Prime Video has tapped into a built-in fanbase that guarantees streaming numbers, even if the films are critically demolished.

FAQs

Why does Culpa Mia have a 0% Rotten Tomatoes score?

Critics overwhelmingly cited weak acting, clichéd storytelling, and lack of originality, resulting in the lowest possible score on Rotten Tomatoes.

Why is Culpa Mia still popular on Prime Video?

Despite poor reviews, the movie is based on a hugely popular Wattpad novel, and fans of the book series continue to support the films, keeping them among the top-streamed titles.

How many movies are in the Culpa Mia franchise?

There are three films based on Mercedes Ron’s novels: Culpa Mia (My Fault), Culpa Tuya (Your Fault), and an upcoming third installment.

What is the audience score for Culpa Mia?

The film holds an 86% audience approval rating, showing a sharp contrast between critical reviews and fan reception.

for further querry feel free to contact us